Maternal gatekeeping describes the phenomenon in which mothers control or dictate the level of a father’s involvement in caring for their children. Consider a scenario where a mother believes her methods for caring for the child are superior, thereby not allowing the father to employ his approach.
This behavior may stem from entrenched beliefs about parental roles or previous experiences. It resembles a gate that can either remain open, allowing fathers to be more active participants, or shut tight, limiting their engagement.
This concept is significant as it influences the co-parenting dynamic and the child’s development. Let’s explore the reasons behind it and its implications for families.
Key Insights:
- Identify gatekeeping behaviors that may hinder your partnership and restrict a father’s engagement; address these together and encourage cooperation to restore trust.
- Foster open dialogue and collaborative parenting to ensure both partners feel acknowledged and equipped; consistently communicate, share responsibilities with confidence, and honor teamwork.
- Question societal norms and seek assistance to alleviate the pressure placed on mothers, acquire varied perspectives, and enhance emotional bonds through shared progress.
What is maternal gatekeeping?
Maternal gatekeeping encompasses the behaviors and mindsets of mothers that determine the extent to which fathers engage in childcare and household tasks. This behavior can be likened to a “gate” that a mother can either open, thereby enabling greater father involvement, or close, thereby restricting it.
Research indicates that mothers are inclined to tighten the gate when they harbor unrealistic perfectionistic expectations regarding the father’s parenting techniques.
This tendency may arise from the mother’s perception of parenting roles, her confidence in the father’s capabilities, or societal expectations about parental responsibilities.
For instance, a mother might believe she knows the optimal way to feed or bathe the child, thus preventing the father from trying his approach.
Although this behavior may originate from a desire to ensure the child’s safety, it can inadvertently minimize the father’s contributions to parenting. Maternal gatekeeping has the potential to reshape family interactions, affecting the parents’ relationship and the overall familial atmosphere.
Grasping this concept is vital for promoting co-parenting and enhancing collaborative efforts between parents.
Examples of maternal gatekeeping
Maternal gatekeeping can appear in various forms, both subtle and explicit. Here are some illustrations of maternal gatekeeping:
- Making remarks like, “Are you really able to handle the kids alone?” can hinder fathers from taking initiative. Such comments imply that the father may lack competence or preparation compared to the mother, leading him to doubt his parenting skills.
Over time, this can cause fathers to become less engaged in their children’s care, increasingly relying on the mother’s direction or interference.
- Statements such as “Daddy is trying, but Mommy knows best” can undermine the father’s confidence and position. Such phrases not only diminish the father’s efforts but also elevate the mother as the primary or superior caregiver.
Children exposed to these statements may begin to perceive their fathers as less competent, influencing the dynamics within their relationships.
- If a father is changing a diaper or preparing a meal and the mother interjects with, “Let me handle this; you’re not doing it correctly,” it can reduce the father’s engagement.
By frequently correcting or taking control of tasks, the mother inadvertently conveys that the father’s methods are subpar. This may discourage fathers from actively participating in future responsibilities, out of fear of criticism or the belief that they will not meet the mother’s expectations.
Impact of maternal gatekeeping: 5 aspects to consider
The repercussions of this gatekeeping behavior can permeate the family unit, impacting relationships, child development, and even the parents’ emotional health. Here are five notable ways maternal gatekeeping influences families:
1. Tension between parents
One immediate consequence of maternal gatekeeping is the strain it places on the parental relationship. When one partner feels obstructed from fully engaging in their child’s life, feelings of resentment, inadequacy, and frustration can arise.
For mothers, the continual need to monitor and control can result in feelings of fatigue and isolation. Over time, this dynamic can erode the foundation of trust and respect that is critical to a healthy relationship.
The term “gatekeeping parenting” captures this dynamic, where controlling behavior by one parent overshadows the collaborative spirit essential for effective co-parenting.
2. Reduced involvement from fathers
Maternal gatekeeping can, unfortunately, diminish a father’s participation in childcare. When faced with constant gatekeeping, fathers might withdraw from taking initiative, fearing negative feedback or doubting their ability to meet the mother’s standards.
This diminished engagement can result in multiple issues. Children may lose out on the diverse perspectives and experiences fathers offer in parenting. Additionally, fathers themselves may feel disconnected, missing the joys and challenges that come with being active parents.
3. Effects on child development
Children flourish best when exposed to a variety of caregiving styles and experiences. When a mother gatekeeps the father from actively participating in the child’s upbringing, it can restrict the child’s opportunities for development.
For example, if a father’s playful and adventurous parenting style is curtailed by gatekeeping, the child might miss out on developing essential skills such as risk assessment, resilience, and even certain motor abilities. Furthermore, children often base their future relationships on the dynamics they observe in their parents.
Experiencing maternal gatekeeping can shape their understanding of gender roles and relationship dynamics, impacting their future partnerships.
4. Child’s emotional health
Children are keen observers and can detect tensions between their parents. Witnessing ongoing gatekeeping behavior can evoke feelings of confusion, guilt, or anxiety.
They might feel torn between their parents or even attribute the discord to themselves. Over time, this emotional distress can manifest in behavioral issues, academic difficulties, or strained peer relationships.
5. Reinforcement of traditional gender roles
Maternal gatekeeping often arises from societal norms and expectations concerning parenting gender roles. When such behaviors persist, they unintentionally reinforce the stereotype that mothers should be the primary caregivers, inherently more attuned to the child’s needs, while fathers are depicted as secondary or less capable caregivers.
This not only restricts fathers from stepping outside traditional roles but also imposes undue pressure on mothers to serve as the primary nurturers, caregivers, and managers of the household. Such reinforcement can perpetuate gender inequalities, both within the family and in broader societal contexts.
7 ways to avoid maternal gatekeeping
Recognizing and addressing the effects of maternal gatekeeping is vital for fostering a harmonious family atmosphere. Here are seven strategies to help you avoid falling into the maternal gatekeeping trap:
1. Promote open communication
Encouraging open conversations is essential. Both mothers and fathers should engage in regular discussions about their roles, expectations, and emotions. If a mother feels anxious about a certain aspect of parenting, addressing it with the father can foster understanding and compromise.
Fathers should also feel free to express their feelings of being sidelined or undervalued.
2. Engage in shared parenting education
Participating in parenting classes or workshops together can be immensely helpful. This approach not only ensures both parents have access to the same information and skills but also reinforces the concept that both are equally responsible and competent caregivers.
Shared educational experiences can level the playing field, decreasing the tendency for mothers to gatekeep based on perceived differences in knowledge.
3. Delegate with trust
Delegation goes beyond merely assigning tasks; it involves entrusting responsibilities. Instead of micromanaging how fathers complete tasks, mothers should trust them to manage responsibilities in their unique ways.
It’s important to remember that there is often more than one correct way to accomplish tasks. By embracing delegation and trust, mothers can resist the impulse to control or intervene.
4. Question societal norms
Social expectations can exert a significant influence on maternal gatekeeping. Mothers frequently encounter external pressures to be the primary caregivers or conform to specific parenting styles. It’s crucial to challenge and scrutinize these norms.
By actively rejecting traditional gender roles and advocating for a more egalitarian approach to parenting, mothers can alleviate the internal and external pressures that give rise to gatekeeping.
5. Explore External Insights
Gaining an outside perspective can be highly advantageous. Engaging in counseling, joining support groups, or simply having conversations with friends can reveal valuable lessons from others’ journeys.
Individuals might recognize gatekeeping behaviors you might not have been aware of or suggest techniques that proved effective for them. An external opinion can serve as both a reality check and a motivation for more inclusive parenting practices.
6. Acknowledge Common Successes
Offering positive reinforcement can make a significant impact. Instead of zeroing in on errors or variations in parenting approaches, focus on celebrating the successes and milestones you achieve together as co-parents.
Whether managing a tough period in your child’s development or seamlessly coordinating schedules, acknowledging and commemorating such moments can enhance your sense of collaboration.
Over time, this mutual recognition can diminish the tendency for gatekeeping, as both parents begin to feel appreciated and competent in their roles.
7. Cultivate Self-Reflection and Awareness
The initial step in preventing maternal gatekeeping is to recognize its presence. Mothers should take a moment to introspect on their actions and attitudes toward their partners. Are you consistently correcting or usurping tasks that the father handles?
Do you maintain the belief that only you know what’s in your child’s best interest? By cultivating self-awareness and introspection, mothers can pinpoint gatekeeping tendencies and actively work to mitigate them.
Commonly asked questions
Here are several additional pertinent questions along with their answers to assist you on your parenting journey.
What makes maternal gatekeeping potentially harmful?
While often motivated by good intentions, maternal gatekeeping can jeopardize a child’s development. Such behavior may prevent a partner from actively participating in childcare, limiting the child’s exposure to varied caregiving experiences, emotional support, and guidance.
Ultimately, it restricts the child’s chances for well-rounded development and balanced relationships.
In what ways can maternal gatekeeping affect a child’s upbringing?
Excessive maternal gatekeeping can narrow a child’s encounters with diverse parenting styles and viewpoints. This might create a dependence on the mother, which can inhibit the child’s emotional growth and resilience.
Additionally, a child may find it challenging to form a robust connection with the non-gatekeeping parent, impacting their self-esteem, social abilities, and overall well-being.
Can maternal gatekeeping occur unintentionally?
Certainly, maternal gatekeeping can happen without any intention. Mothers may resort to such behaviors out of a sincere wish to safeguard their child’s welfare, often believing they are uniquely qualified for the role.
This behavior frequently arises from societal norms and expectations, rather than an explicit desire to limit the other parent’s participation. Identifying unintentional gatekeeping is an essential step toward promoting a more balanced parenting dynamic.
What prompts mothers to engage in maternal gatekeeping?
Mothers tend to participate in maternal gatekeeping due to a mix of societal pressures, personal beliefs about parenting duties, and worries regarding their child’s well-being. Often, they may feel more capable or knowledgeable about childcare, resulting in controlling actions regarding the father’s involvement.
What is the gatekeeper’s role in parenting?
In exploring the concept of gatekeeping in relationships and families, the gatekeeper’s role in parenting is to manage or affect the other parent’s participation in child-rearing activities.
This can either promote collaboration and shared responsibilities or restrict and inhibit the other parent’s involvement, significantly influencing family dynamics.
Getting rid of the gatekeeping
Maternal gatekeeping, although frequently stemming from sincere concerns or societal influences, can significantly affect family dynamics. It’s crucial for families to identify and address these behaviors to create a more inclusive and harmonious parenting climate.
By grasping the complexities of gatekeeping and advocating for open dialogue and cooperation, families can ensure both parents play an active role in their child’s upbringing, enriching their lives with varied caregiving experiences.
Family dynamics fundamentally influence our experiences of love, safety, and belonging. They shape how we communicate, cope with stress, and connect with one another. Often, these patterns go unnoticed until there’s tension or distance that arises.
Other Articles
15 Comments
Comments are closed.
A must read for anyone with children in their lives. I have been an avid consumer of Britt Hawthorn’s content for years now and quite frankly I didn’t expect to be as enthralled with this book as I am. Britt and Natasha have written a book for parents but really it is for anyone who has children in their community. As a person without children of my own but with children in my community, I expected to have to look for ways to adapt what Britt and Natasha had written, but I was wrong. This book is for parents, teachers, aunties, uncles, grandparents, coaches and caretakers of all kinds. This is a guide for anyone with children in their lives. Britt has written a gentle but firm call to action, full of grace and accountability to help us provide the following generations the tools we weren’t afforded growing up.Written with collaborators to include voices of other perspectives, this book helps to center voices and perspectives that have been left out of the conversation for far too long. This book is titled “Raising Antiracist Children” but when reading you learn that it is about even more than that, it is about raising humans with compassion, who seek justice, and who work to look through a multifaceted lens.It can seem difficult and daunting to walk this path alone, often not knowing where to start or feeling awkward pauses and moments when not knowing what to say. Britt writes with thoughtfulness, humility, compassion and vulnerability as she shares her journey as a parent and educator. She brings her years of knowledge as a parent and also teacher as she shares the lessons she has learned and unlearned to help us walk this path alongside her.
A must-read for caregivers~. Disclaimer: I was given an advanced review copy in exchange for an honest review but I have also purchased my own copy, the audiobook, and several other copies to give away (yes, it’s THAT good).If you are a parent, caregiver, grandparent, teacher, or living human being, you need to read this book and buy it for the people in your life. It’s the book I wish I had when my children were young. Britt has a beautiful way of communicating and giving language to many things that I have only been able to feel but not express.The book is broken down into five parts: deepening our understandings, healthy bodies, radical minds, conscious consumption, and thriving communities. It lists all contributors with bio’s, cites sources, offers additional reading recommendations for each section, bibliography, and index for easy reference.My favorite part is probably the different activities, playful imagination examples, practical examples of incorporating lessons with children with questions and reflective prompts (on a walk, pointing out a crack in the sidewalk and asking your child why it is a problem and who it affects, then going home and calling 311 with your child to report the problem so it can be fixed) gentle ways to correct kids, ways to set boundaries with family, teachers, etc. and so much more.If I had one complaint? It would be that Britt is not the voice on the audiobook. Yes, I’m biased. From being a part of her online community, I know that she has such a gentle (yet strong) and kind spirit and exudes such gratitude. The reader was great…Britt just would have been better.
This Book! This Book. I pre-ordered this book April 30 th and received it June 7 th . I finished reading it July 16 th 2022.This is the first book I have read this fast in over 30 years.This book is an exceptional and outstanding literary work, professional, historical, evidencebased research, cutting edge, forward thinking relative to dismantling white supremacy andracism in America.This book describes practical solutions to enhance equality for all and details advocating for trueliberation in the United States.This book is worthy of a Doctorate Degree in Education. It could be submitted, defended andapproved before a committee of their peers as an exemplary body of knowledge in highereducation.This book seems to be targeted towards teachers pre-school to 8 th grade. It cuts across manydisciplines and theories in: Social Work, African American History, Political Science, USGovernment, Psychology, Psychiatry, Education and Sociology.This book should be in every library and school districts across the country, on required readinglists for the disciplines referenced above.I have a Bachelors of Science Degree in Psychology, Master’s of Social Work Degree with aconcentration in Mental Health Administration.I have over 45 years of work experience between The Department of Veterans Affairs, RockfordPublic School District and Community Mental Health Center.I have senior memberships in The National Association of Social Workers and NationalAssociation of Cognitive-Behavioral Therapists.I am an African American Cisgender, married, male, he/him/his, and Licensed Clinical SocialWorker/Therapist in private practice in Rockford, IL.I have raised three African American/Belarusian children over the past 30 years and highlyrecommend this book as a Parenting Guide in Raising Antiracist Children as the next generationof leaders in America.Leon Black, MSW, LCSW, CCBT
game changer for parenting. This book has changed the way I parent. I have two daughters, 1 and 6 years old. The oldest struggles with elevated levels of anxiety to the point where we decided to have her start chatting with a pediatric therapist to help her (and us) better navigate the tough moments. Her therapist recommends that all parents read this book. I am so thankful that I did. I not only understand more about my daughter’s brain and thought process and emotions, but I also understand more about myself, and how my handling of situations has projected my own anxiety onto her. The good news is that we can actually change our brains by forming new neural pathways, and it’s never too late to start. So you can take situations that normally upset your child (anxiety, fear, anger, violence, hyersilliness, nervousness, inability to focus – truly anything) and use these occurrences to help them form new neural pathways that in turn allow them to better cope with challenges. And it’s helped me in the same way. I’ve noticed I am better able to manage high-anxiety situations in general. This book does an amazing job at explaining just enough of the science to help the concepts make logical sense. For me, this makes them easier to remember and implement. After reading this book, I *get* it. And that makes all the difference in the world when you are in an emotional moment, struggling to best navigate not only your little one’s feelings but also your own. Beyond the concepts, this book provides practical, easy to understand techniques. And darn it if they don’t work. I noticed such a rapid response with my 6-year-old that I started using some of the approaches with my 1-year-old, and there was an immediate response with her as well. Getting such quick and positive feedback makes you excited to keep using the approaches. And it’s really set up to be as easy as possible. There is a helpful “HOW TO USE THIS BOOK” section at the beginning, I’ve included some snippets in my photos. I think this book is a game changer for parenting, and I wish I had read it earlier. I recommend this to any parent, new or veteran.
Co parenting must. I highly recommend! Such an easy read with a lot of great tips to add to your everyday life. Very helpful!
A must-read for any expecting dad. “The Pregnancy Guide for Men” by Bob Stone is a must-read for any expecting dad. It’s a comprehensive and relatable guide covering every stage of pregnancy, labor, and early parenthood. Stone’s practical advice on navigating medical info, supporting your partner, and preparing for the big day is invaluable. The book’s personal touch and empathetic approach make it both informative and engaging. Highly recommended for dads-to-be looking to thrive and support their partners effectively!
Very knowledgeable. I’ve picked up a lot of knowledge from this book, it is absolutely “the” book which every upcoming parent should purchase !
For father’s during pregnancy. I just finished reading Pregnancy Guide for Men, a fascinating and insightful exploration of the often-overlooked experience of dads during pregnancy. The author masterfully weaves together personal anecdotes, expert interviews, and scientific research to create a comprehensive and compassionate portrait of the emotional, physical, and psychological journey of expectant fathers.From the initial shock of discovering they’re going to be a dad to the anxiety and excitement of awaiting the baby’s arrival, this book shines a light on the complex emotions and transformations that men undergo during this pivotal life moment.What resonated most with me was the author’s emphasis on the importance of support and community for expectant dads, who often feel left out of the pregnancy conversation. This book is a must-read for anyone looking to better understand and support the dads-to-be in their lives.”
A Guide to Navigating the Storm od Co-Parenting; including parental alienation. This great book offers a comprehensive guide for navigating the complexities of post-divorce parenting. A standout feature is its insightful exploration of parental alienation, a toxic dynamic often overlooked in such discussions. The book provides practical tools and strategies to protect children from this harmful behavior that results in mild alienation, empowering parents to foster healthy relationships and resilient kids. However, for severe parental alienation, find books with “parental alienation’ in the title and include books with information on how to present your case to the courts to protect your children.For more books on parental alienation, see this wish list: https://www.amazon.com/hz/wishlist/ls/1NC8GYD2NCP9P?ref_=wl_share
Great impact on better child of shared custody. Good source for impartial “how to” parent a toddler in a strained separation/divorse situation.
Father parenting guide. This Father parenting guide for new fathers navigating the exhilarating yet challenging journey of parenthood. With its practical advice and relatable anecdotes, the book offers game-winning strategies for bonding with babies, mastering essential care techniques, and confidently facing the ups and downs of fatherhood. Each chapter is packed with valuable insights that blend humor with heartfelt guidance, making it an enjoyable read. The playbook emphasizes the importance of engagement and connection, providing actionable tips that empower dads to be present and supportive. Whether you’re changing diapers or establishing bedtime routines, this book serves as a reassuring companion, helping first-time dads feel prepared and excited for the adventure ahead.
Essential Guide for New Dads: Practical and Empowering. Stepping into fatherhood for the first time can feel like being thrust into the championship game without a playbook. Enter “The First-Time Dad Playbook,” a lifesaver for rookie dads aiming to score big in the parenting league.This guide is packed with straightforward advice, breaking down the complexities of baby care into digestible, actionable steps. From mastering diaper changes to understanding your baby’s cues, it covers the fundamentals with clarity and a touch of humor.What sets this book apart is its focus on building a strong bond with your newborn. It emphasizes the importance of being present and engaged, offering creative ways to connect with your little one from day one.The author’s tone is refreshingly encouraging, making you feel like you’re getting advice from a seasoned friend rather than a textbook. The inclusion of real-life anecdotes adds relatability, reminding you that you’re not alone on this journey.In a nutshell, “The First-Time Dad Playbook” is an invaluable resource for any new father. It’s like having a coach in your corner, guiding you through the challenges and triumphs of early parenthood. With this book in hand, you’ll feel more confident and prepared to tackle the adventures of fatherhood head-on.
relatable and practical playbook. This guide for first time dads is a relatable and practical playbook for navigating parenthood. It’s packed with helpful tips, humor, and heartfelt advice, and it covers bonding, baby care, and building routines with confidence. Every child and situation is unique, but the book offers a roadmap for dads who want to be engaged and supportive. It is a great resource to prepare for the challenges and joys of fatherhood—perfect for first-time dads or anyone seeking guidance. I can’t wait to share this with my son!
Insightful, Practical, and Parenting-Changing. The Whole-Brain Child gave me tools I didn’t even know I needed. It breaks down complex brain science into simple, relatable strategies that actually help in day-to-day parenting. The techniques for connecting with your child before correcting really work—and they’ve helped reduce meltdowns and build stronger relationships at home. I love the real-life examples, illustrations, and age-specific suggestions. It’s empowering without being overwhelming. Whether you’re a new parent or an experienced one, this book is a must-read for understanding how kids think and feel.
If you are considering this book, get it. This book is absolutely a must have. I have a degree in Christian counseling, and this was one of the texts we read. I was in the field of social work for a while, and I frequently taught from this book. If you think about it, I had a digital copy and ended up buying a physical copy, if that tells you anything. This is a great text for social workers, therapists, and even exasperated moms and dads. It breaks down challenging mental health concepts in an easily understandable way that is not overloaded with jargon. The methods in it work. I cannot recommend this book enough.